Ex-Abercrombie CEO Mike Jeffries Pleads Not Guilty to Federal Sex Trafficking Charges

Mike Jeffries, who led Abercrombie & Fitch from 1992 to 2014, pleaded not guilty to a series of federal charges, including sex trafficking and interstate prostitution. Accusations against Jeffries and his British-American partner, Matthew Smith, center on allegations of exploiting young men through a sophisticated operation involving deception, coercion, and manipulation of modeling aspirations. Jeffries, 80, appeared in court alongside his alleged accomplice, James Jacobson, who also pleaded not guilty to charges of recruiting men for illegal activities. Both men have been released on bond pending further legal proceedings.

Background on Allegations: Claims of Coercion and Exploitation

Federal prosecutors allege that Jeffries, Smith, and Jacobson organized a clandestine operation that targeted young men aspiring to model, enticing them with promises of career opportunities that never materialized. According to the indictment, the men allegedly hosted events involving coercive sexual encounters at various locations, including private residences and international venues. Jacobson, reportedly serving as a recruiter, is accused of paying or promising to pay young men to attend these events, where prosecutors claim they were pressured or even forcibly administered substances like Viagra, alcohol, and muscle relaxants.

In a public statement, Breon Peace, U.S. Attorney for the Eastern District of New York, claimed Jeffries and Smith invested “prolific amounts of money” in recruiting men to engage in these activities, which often involved restrictive non-disclosure agreements.

BBC Investigation Reveals Disturbing Details

The case against Jeffries and Smith follows a year-long FBI probe initiated after a 2023 BBC investigation. This investigation uncovered claims from several men who alleged they were misled into attending events that escalated into non-consensual encounters. The men involved claimed Jacobson coordinated the gatherings and served as an intermediary between Jeffries and the young men he allegedly exploited. The investigation also unearthed reports of manipulation, with some victims alleging they were injected with unknown substances.

According to the indictment, dozens of men were affected by the alleged scheme, and prosecutors have officially identified 15 individuals as victims, who were reportedly pressured to remain silent through non-disclosure agreements. Abercrombie & Fitch, the company Jeffries once led to immense popularity, has distanced itself from the case, stating it is “appalled and disgusted” by the accusations. The company added that it has undergone significant cultural reforms since Jeffries’ departure.

Court Proceedings: A High-Stakes Hearing and Strict Conditions

During a recent 10-minute hearing in New York, U.S. Magistrate Judge Steven Tiscione informed Jeffries of the terms of his house arrest. Jeffries remains under strict GPS-monitored confinement, permitted to leave only for essential purposes such as medical care, legal consultations, and religious services. His bond was set at $10 million, secured by his residence in Fisher Island, New York. Jacobson, 71, also faces similar restrictions, secured on a $500,000 bond.

One of Jeffries' alleged victims, David Bradberry, attended the hearing, listening as charges were read. Despite media presence outside the courtroom, Jeffries left without addressing reporters, escorted by his legal team.

Charges and Possible Penalties

If convicted, Jeffries and his associates could face a maximum penalty of life in prison. The charges of sex trafficking alone carry a potential life sentence, while interstate prostitution could result in a 20-year sentence. The trial could bring further revelations as prosecutors aim to present additional testimonies and evidence, with the next court appearance scheduled for December 12.

Jeffries’ legal counsel, Brian Bieber, entered the not-guilty plea on his client’s behalf, maintaining that the hearing was “procedural.” Bieber declined further comments, focusing on the bond conditions and procedural nature of Friday’s court proceedings.

Former Abercrombie CEO’s Legacy and Corporate Culture Reforms

Jeffries’ tenure as Abercrombie CEO was marked by bold marketing and controversial business strategies that popularized the brand among teens but also drew criticism for promoting exclusionary standards. Under his leadership, Abercrombie was frequently embroiled in controversies, including accusations of discrimination and objectification in advertising.

Abercrombie & Fitch has emphasized its efforts to reshape its corporate culture in response to public scrutiny. The brand states it has pivoted towards inclusive values and aims to maintain a supportive workplace. Abercrombie shares have notably declined since the news broke, reflecting investor concerns regarding the ongoing legal case.

Public Reaction and Corporate Responsibility

The accusations against Jeffries underscore an ongoing societal reckoning with abuse of power within corporations. Public interest in the case highlights the need for transparency and accountability from industry leaders. Abercrombie & Fitch has not been charged with any involvement in the criminal case, but it remains the subject of separate civil litigation.

As Jeffries prepares to face court again in December, the proceedings will likely renew discussions around corporate ethics and reinforce the importance of rigorous investigations. The case also prompts a reevaluation of recruitment and hiring practices in industries like fashion, where vulnerable individuals may seek opportunities only to face potential exploitation.